
    Filed April 22, 1890.
    John O’Connor, Resp’t, v. The National Ice Co. of New York, App’lt.
    
      Alex. Thain, for resp’t; E. D. McCarthy, for app’lt.
   Judgment affirmed, with costs. All concur, except Earl and Gray, JJ.,. dissenting.

Affirming 21 N. Y. State Rep., 907.  