
    Fourth Department,
    January Term, 1889.
    Charles E. Lee, Respondent, v. John P. Laughlin, Appellant, Impleaded with Patrick Bird and James Bird.
   Order reversed, with ten dollars costs and printing disbursements. Verdict and judgment set aside, with ten dollars costs, and new trial granted. Opinion Per Guriajm, filed with clerk of Onondaga county. Kennedy, J., not sitting.  