
    James Ludington v. David A. Melendy.
    Error to Mason.
    Submitted April 28.
    Decided Nov. 10.
    Attachment. Defendant brings error.
    Affirmed.
    
      White & McMahon for plaintiff in error.
    
      C. G. Wing and Geo. H. Noyes for defendant in error.
   Cooley, J.

In this case the judges have been unable to come to an agreement respecting the matters assigned for error, and the judgment of the circuit court will therefore stand affirmed but without costs.

The other Justices concurred.  