
    Homer Mandeville, Respondent, v. Henry A. Guernsey, Appellant.
    (Argued April 25, 1872;
    decided November 12, 1872.)
    
      George B. Bradley for the appellant.
    
      John W. Dininy for the respondent.
   For affirmance—Church, Ch. J.

Allen, Peckham and Andrews, JJ., concur.

For reversal—Grover, Folger and Rapallo, JJ.

Judgment affirmed. Ho opinion.  