
    Michael McParlin et al., Respondents, v. Eben M. Boynton, Appellant.
    (Argued September 25,1877;
    decided November 27,1877.)
    Reported below, 8 Hun, 449.
    
      Nathaniel C. Moak, for appellant.
    
      C. Bainbridge Smith, for respondents.
   Allen, Folger, Andrews and Earl, JJ.,

agree to affirm,

without opinion; Miller, J., reads for reversal; Church, Ch. J., and Rapallo, J., concur.

Judgment affirmed.  