
    [No. 1701.
    Decided May 21, 1895.]
    George Lewis Gower, Appellant, v. City of Tacoma et al., Respondents.
    
    
      Appeal from Superior Court, Pierce County.
    
    
      Tillotson & Milligan, for appellant.
    
      James Wickersham, and Stacy W. Gibbs, for respondents.
   Dunbar, J.

This case presents the same questions involved in No. 1696, Newman Kline v. City of Tacoma, just decided; but as the cases were tried by different judges different conclusions were reached, and for the reasons stated in Kline v. Tacoma, supra, the judgment in this case will be reversed.

Gordon and Soott, JJ., concur.

Hoyt, C. J., dissents.  