
    No. 128.
    Noyes v. Silver Queen Mining Company.
    Certificate from the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
    Submitted December 1, 1897.
    Decided December 6, 1897.
    
      Mr. W. H. Doolittle for Noyes.
    
      Mr. John H. Miller for the Mining Company.
   Question answered in the negative on the authority of Thorp v. Bonnifield, 168 IT. S. 703, and cases cited.  