
    DAVIS v. CAMMEYER.
    (Circuit Court, S. D. New York.
    January 30, 1897.)
    Patents — Preliminary Injunction — Denial.
    Motion for preliminary injunction. Suit on patent No. 242,382, dated May 31, 1881,. to Michael Shuter and Abraham Davis, for “tip for insoles,” and sustained on final hearing in Shuter v. Davis, 16 Fed. 564. Denied.
    Edwin H. Brown, for complainant.
    Philip J. O’Reilly, for defendant.
   LACOMBE, Circuit Judge.

The articles used in the defendant’s shoes are not in all respects like those which, in the former suit, were held to be infringements of the patent. While the variances are not perhaps great, the patent is a narrow one, and the determination of the question whether these particular tips are also infringements may best be reserved for final hearing.  