
    Thomas R. Rutherford, Assignee, etc., Resp’t, v. Julius Schattman, Impl'd, etc., App’lt.
    
      J F. Parkhurst, for resp’t; Rudolph Sampler, for app’lt.
   Judgment affirmed, with costs. All concur, except Ruger, Ch. J., dissenting.

Affirming 17 N. Y. State Rep., 363.  