
    PREMO against SMITH.
    
      New York Superior Court;
    
    
      General Term, May, 1870.
    Stay of Proceedings. —Discovery.
    Where plaintiff fraudulently makes way with evidence of defendant’s rights, material to the action, his proceedings may be stayed until he shall produce it. .
    Appeal from an order.
    The action was brought by John Premo against Philip Smith.
    
      
      John E. Parsons, for the appellant.
    
      James W. Culver, for the respondent.
   By the Court.—Freedman, J.

This is an appeal from an order staying plaintiff’s proceedings. Upon the hearing of the motion below, the defendant showed by affidavit, and by the records of the court of common pleas for the city and county of New York, that the plaintiff had willfully and fraudulently either destroyed or withheld from the defendant the original specifications of a written building contract, which defined the rights of the parties to the action, and were material for the determination of such rights. The plaintiff read no papers in opposition to the motion, and the court thereupon granted an order staying all proceedings on the part of the plaintiff in the action, until he shall produce and deliver to the attorney for the defendant one of the said original specifications, and giving to the defendant twenty days after such service to answer the complaint or take such other proceedings in the action as he shall be advised.

Upon an examination of the facts it clearly appears that the court below had not only the power to make the order appealed from, but that the order, as made, was a proper one under the circumstances.

The order should be affirmed, with costs. 
      
       Present, Barbour, Ch. J., and Freedman and Spencer, JJ.
     