
    Tate v. Philadelphia et al.
    Argued August 31,1945.
    Before Maxey, C. J., Drew, Linn, Patterson and Jones, JJ.
    
      Joseph Sharfsin and Louis F. McCabe, for petitioner.
    
      William T. Connor, for respondents.
    September 24, 1945:
   Opinion by

Mr. Chief Justice Maxey,

The petition is dismissed at the cost of the plaintiff for the reasons set forth in the companion case of Kane v. Morrison, Secretary of tbe Common-wealth et al., in which an opinion has been this day filed.

Concurring Opinion by

Mr. Justice Jones:

I concur in the result for the reasons given in separate concurrence in Kane v. Morrison, Secretary of the Commonwealth et al., p. 611, supra.  