
    Argued October 15,
    decided November 17, 1908.
    COFFEY v. STOCK.
    [97 Pac. 1081.]
    From Multnomah: Arthur L. Frazer, Judge.
    Suit by B. D..Coffey against Anna Stock, O. M. Smith et al. to establish and foreclose a mechanic’s lien. From a decree in favor of plaintiff, defendants appeal.
    Reversed.
    
      For appellant there was a brief and an oral argument by Mr. John H. Hall.
    
    For respondent there was a brief with oral arguments by Mr. Andrew T. Lewis and Mr. Walter G. Hayes.
    
   Opinion by

Mr. Commissioner Slater.

This is a suit to establish and foreclose an alleged mechanic’s lien upon a dwelling house constructed upon lot 1, block 11, West Piedmont, Multnomah County. The material facts in this case are identical with those in the case of Coffey v. Smith et al. 52 Or. 538 (97 Pac. 1079), and the conclusion there reached is controlling here, and the same decree should be entered.

Reversed.  