
    VAILE v. MOFFAT.
    (Circuit Court, S. D. New York.
    January 27, 1909.)
    Upon Motion to Remand.
    Barbour, Rush, Hare & Haller, for plaintiff.
    Alexander & Green, for defendant.
   NOYES, Circuit Judge.

While regarding the question raised upon this motion as a doubtful one, I have concluded to follow the decision in Barlow v. Chicago, etc., R. Co. (C. C.) 164 Fed. 765, and to deny the motion to remand. An order may be entered accordingly.  