
    CONSTANT, Appellant, v. SCHLOSS et al., Respondents.
    (City Court of New York, General Term.
    January 18, 1899.)
    Action by Samuel Victor Constant, as assignee, against Gustave E. Schloss and another. L. A. Gould, for appellant. Oppenheim & Severance, for respondent.
   O’DWYER, J.

We are of the opinion that at special term the plaintiff made a case entitling him to a portion of the particulars demanded, and that the order appealed from should be reversed, with costs, and the motion granted, without costs, as prayed for-in the notice of motion, with the exception that the defendant need not furnish any particulars as to the respect in which the shellac was of an inferior quality, and not strictly pure and. first class. OLCOTT, J., concurs.  