
    COURT OF APPEALS.
    
      Decisions—January Term, 1848
    
      at the Capitol in the city of Albany.
    
    Melancthon W. Danks, plaintiff in error, vs. Jeremiah D. Quackenbush, defendant in error.
    
      Judgment affirmed,.
    
    A. Taber, for plain tiff in error;
    George F. Comstock, for defendant in error.
   The decision in this case affirmed (by an equal division of the judges,) the decision of the Supreme Court, declaring the unconstitutionality of the act of April 11, 1842, extending the exemption of personal property, as to debts contracted before its passage. (Reported, 1 Comstock, 129.)  