
    No. 11469.
    The City of Columbus et al. v. Irvine.
    Decided January 18, 1910.
    Error to Circuit Court of Franklin county.
    
      Mr. George S. Marshall, city solicitor, and Messrs. W-einland, Hoover, Carter & Davies, for plaintiffs in error.
    
      Messrs'. Arnold, Morton & Irvine, for defendant in error.
   Judgment affirmed.

Spear, Davis, Shauck and Price, JJ., concur. Summers, C. J., dissents.  