
    696.
    Williams v. Wolff.
    Certiorari, from Bichmond superior court — Judge Hammond. June 25, 1907.
    Submitted November 26, 1907.
    Decided February 24, 1908.
    
      Isaac S. Peebles Jr., for plaintiff.
    
      Samuel II. Myers, Wallace B. Pierce, for defendant.
   Hill, C. J.

It was error to permit the testimony of a witness, given in a previous trial of the same ease, to be introduced in evidence without preliminary proof that the witness was “deceased, or disqualified, or inaccessible;” and for this reason the certiorari was properly sustained. Civil Code, § 5186. ' Judgment affirmed.  