
    Caroline C. Piper, Resp’t, v. John L. Hoard, App’lt.
    
      A M. Beardsley, for resp’t; O. B. Adams, for app’lt.
   Judgment affirmed, with costs. All concur, except Ruger, Ch, J., dissenting. „ „„„

Affirming 19 N. Y. State Rep., 303.  