
    Supreme Court, New York Special Term.
    Reported. N. Y. L. J.,
    August 21, 1902.
    In the Matter of the Petition of Charles E. Horner to Revoke the Liquor Tax Certificate of Kyrie D. Clemons.
    
      Frank L. Mayliam, attorney for petitioner.
    
      Black, Olcott, Gruber £ Bonynge, attorneys for respondent.
    
      3. 3. Kellogg, attorney for department.
   Hall, J.:

A careful examination of the testimony in this case, allowing full weight to all the evidence and exhibits offered by the respondent, in my opinion, brings it squarely within the doctrine laid down in Re Selmyler (63 App. Div. 206). The facts in the two cases are very similar. The petitioner is entitled to judgment revoking the certificate, with costs.

Settle form of judgment on notice.  