
    THE A. B. VALENTINE. WESTERN ASSUR. CO. OF TORONTO v. CORNELL STEAMBOAT CO.
    (Circuit Court of Appeals, Second Circuit.
    December 21, 1893.)
    No. 59.
    Collision—Steamer and Tug with Tow.
    Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Northern District of New York.
    This was a libel by the Western Assurance Company of Toronto against the steamer A. B. Valentine, the Cornell Steamboat Company, claimant, to recover damages sustained by a canal boat by reason of a collision with the Valentine. In the district court the libel was dismissed. 55 Fed. 350. Libelant appeals.
    . George Clinton, for appellant.
    Amos Van Etten, for appellee.
   Decree affirmed, without an opinion, on the opinion of the district judge.  