
    James F. Malcolm, Resp’t, v. The Manhattan R. Co. et al., App’lts.
    
      Bsek Cowen, for resp’t; Sidney Smith, for app’lts.
   Judgment reversed, new trial granted, costs to abide event, on authority of Roberts v. Sarnie Def't, 138 N. Y., 455; 40 St. Bep., 454; Boyle v. Same, 138 B. Y., 488; 40 St. Bep., 474; Cray v. Same, 138 N. Y., 499; 40 St. Bep., 478.

All concur, except Gray, J., not voting.

Beversing 40 St. Bep., 983.  