
    COUCH PATENTS CO. v. NEW YORK WOVEN WIRE MATTRESS CO.
    (Circuit Court, S. D. New York.
    May 23, 1907.)
    Action in equity to restrain alleged infringement of claims 1 to 8, inclusive, and claim 12, of United States letters patent No. 712,718, to Adrian de Piniec-Mallet, dated November 4, 1002, for extensible bedstead or couch.
    Charles Neave and Linzee Blagden, for complainant.
    Roberts & Mitchell and Charles C. Gill (Odin Roberts, of counsel), for defendant.
   RAY, District Judge.

On the whole, and id view of the prior art, I am satisfied of the validity of the claims of the patent in suit, and that defendant infringes. Anticipation is not established. There will be a decree for complainant, with costs.  