
    Horace Shipman, Respondent, v. Harry Williams, Appellant.
    (Submitted. October 4, 1872;
    decided January term, 1873.)
    Decided upon the facts in the case.
    
      Harry Williams, appellant, in person.
    
      F. B. Smith for the respondent.
   Gray, C.,

reads for affirmance.

All concur.

Judgment affirmed.  