
    Case No. 8,838.
    In re MACKAY.
    [4 N. B. R. 67 (Quarto, 17).] 
    
    District Court, S. D. New York.
    1870.
    Bankruptcy — Discharge—Proper Books op Account.
    Where discharge was refused bankrupt for failing to keep proper books of account.
    [In the matter of John Maxwell Maekay, a bankrupt For prior proceedings in this case, see Case No. 8,837.]
    T. C. F. Buckley, for creditor.
    G. C. Barrett, for bankrupt
    
      
       [Reprinted by permission.]
    
   BLATCHFORD, District Judge.

Having come to the conclusion, on the evidence, that the bankrupt was, in fact, as a merchant and trader, a member with John Murdock Mae-kay and John Neilson, of the copartnership firm of J. M. Maekay & Co., a discharge must be refused to him, for the reasons set forth for refusing discharges to those persons; the specifications in opposition to his discharge as a member of said firm, as a merchant and trader, being to the same effect as in respect to them, in regard to the keeping of proper books of account.  