
    GRAHAM v. MANUFACTURERS CAS. INS. CO. et al.
    No. 8174.
    Court of Appeal of Louisiana. Second Circuit.
    June 25, 1954.
    Rehearing Denied July 16, 1954.
    Jackson, Mayer & Kennedy, Shreveport, for appellants.
    Hobbs & Yeates, Mindem for appellee.
    Gravel & Downs, Alexandria, for inter-venor.
   GLADNEY, Judge.

Francis A. Graham, plaintiff and appel-lee herein, suffered personal injuries in the accident of December 11, 1951, on U. S. Highway 80 involving a truck in which he was a passenger. Our findings on the issues of fact and law given in Vowell v. Manufacturer’s Casualty Insurance Company, La.App., 73 So.2d 583, are equally applicable to the instant case and our decision therein is controlling here.

In addition to our conclusions in the Vowell decision we find defendant’s plea of contributory negligence meritorious as we think Graham’s negligence was the proximate cause of the accident.

It is therefore ordered that the judgment from which appealed be and the same is hereby annulled, set aside and reversed and plaintiff’s action dismissed. It is further ordered that the judgment in favor of the intervenor is annulled, set aside and reversed and intervenor’s claim is denied. Costs to be prorated equally between plaintiffs.

AYRES, J., concurs in the decree.  