
    Julia A. Shipman, Respondent, v. Oswego and Onondaga Insurance Company, Appellant.
    (Argued December 3, 1879 ;
    
    decided January 13, 1880.)
    
      Samuel Hand for appellant.
    O. W. Chapman for respondent.
   Agree to affirm without opinion.

All concur, except Rapallo, J., dissenting and reading opinion.

Judgment affirmed.  