
    [Civ. No. 4981.
    First Appellate District, Division One.
    October 22, 1924.]
    DAVID McKIBBIN, Appellant, v. FRANK C. SYKES et al., Respondents.
    
       Municipal Corporations — Ban Francisco ■—Firemen’s Belief Fund.-—Judgment reversed upon authority of Ewrley V. Sylces, ante, p. 310.
    APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of the City and County of San Francisco. James M. Troutt, Judge. Reversed.
    - The question involved in this case is in all respects similar to that in Hurley v.’ Sylces, ante, p. 310.
    Sloss, Ackerman & Bradley for Appellant.
    George Lull, City Attorney, and Maurice T. Dooling, Jr., Assistant 'City Attorney, for Respondents.
   St. SURE, J.

The question involved in this ease is in-all respects similar to that in Hurley v. Sykes et al., ante, p. 310 [231 Pac. 748]. Upon the authority of that case it is ordered that the' judgment he reversed and that a decree be entered in favor of appellant, with the direction that the writ issue.

Tyler, P. J., and Knight, J., concurred.  