
    [No. 381.
    Decided January 6, 1892.)
    Frank Paul, Respondent, v. Herman Chapin, et al., Appellants.
    
    
      Appeal from Superior Court, King County.
    
    
      Gale, Fay & Henderson, for appellants.
    
      Andrews & Barnes, for respondent.
   Stiles, J.

This case is identical with Paul v. Furth, and Paul v. McGraw, ante, p. 296, in which decision was heretofore filed (Dec. 9), and upon the authority of those cases the judgment herein is reversed.

Anders, C. J., and Dunbar, Scott & Hoyt, JJ., concur.

REPORTS OF CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OP THE STATE OF WASHINGTON, AT THE JANUARY SESSION, 1892.  