
    Aaron A. De Grauw, Respondent, v. James H. Elmore, Appellant.
    (Argued February 21, 1873;
    decided September 23, 1873.)
    
      Samuel Hand for the appellant.
    
      John E. Parsons for the respondent.
   For affirmance Peckham, Folger, Andrews and Rapallo, JJ.

Allen, J., reads for reversal and new trial.

Church, Ch. J., and Grover, J., concur.

No prevailing opinion.

Judgment affirmed.  