
    Shirley v. Shirley.
    February 25, 1910.
    Action for damages. Before Judge Kimsey. Babun superior court.
    December 21, 1908.
    
      T. L. Bynum and W. S. Paris, for plaintiff.
    
      Robert McMillan and E. E. Dean, .for defendant.
   Beck, J.

1. When considered in connection with the charge as a whole, certain excerpts therefrom, upon which error was assigned, idid not furnish sufficient cause for the grant of a new trial.

2. The verdict in favor of the defendant was authorized by the evidence, and the discretion of the judge in refusing a new trial will not be disturbed.

Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur.  