
    James W. Simonton, Respondent, v. Empire Sewing Machine Co., Appellant.
    (Argued March. 15, 1873;
    decided June term, 1873.)
    Decided on the facts in the case.
    
      John J. Townsend for the appellant.
    
      Samuel A. Noyes for the respondent.
   Gray, C.,

reads for affirmance.

Reynolds, C.,

for reversal.

All concur for affirmance, except Reynolds, C., dissenting. Judgment affirmed.  