
    The Oscar Barnett Foundry Company, respondent, v. Paul L. Crowe, appellant.
    [Submitted March 25th, 1912.
    Decided June 20th, 1912.]
    On appeal from a decree of the court of chancery advised by Vice-Chancellor Iiowell, whose opinion is reported ante p.
    
    
      Messrs. Lum, Tamblyn & Golyer, for the respondent.
    
      Mr. Boyd McLean, for the appellant.
   Per Curiam.

The decree appealed from will be affirmed'for the reasons stated in the opinion filed in the court below by Vice-Chancellor Howell.

For affirmance—The Chancellor, Garrison, Swayze, Trenci-iard, Mint urn, ICalisch, Vroom, Congdon, White —9.

For reversal—The Chief-Justice, Parker, Bergen, Voori-iees,.Bogert, Vredenbukgh, Treacy—1.  