
    McFarlane, Respondent, v. Industrial Commission and another, Appellants: Hardware Mutual Casualty Company, Respondent.
    
      October 10
    
    November 5, 1958.
    
    
      For the appellant Industrial Commission there was a brief by the Attorney General and Mortimer Levitan, assistant attorney general, and oral argument by Mr. Levitcm.
    
    For the respondent Wynne McFarlane there was a brief by Callahan & Arnold of Columbus, and oral argument by E. Clarke Arnold.
    
    For the respondent Hardware Mutual Casualty Company there was a brief by Toebaas, Hart, Kraege & Jackman of Madison, and oral argument by W. L. Jackman.
    
   Per Curiam.

Of the justices participating in the determination of this case two voted for affirmance and two voted for reversal of the judgment of the circuit court. Under our rules, therefore, the judgment is affirmed without opinion.

Martin, C. J., and Brown and Fairchild, JJ., took no part.  