
    Before the First Division,
    April 1, 1953
    No. 57232.
    protest 159945-K (New York).
    Geigy Co., Inc. v. United States,
   Opinion by

Oliver, C. J.

The undisputed facts showed that the product in question is a color or .dye, soluble in water, used for blueing textiles, principally bleached cotton cloth, making it whiter, and that it is obtained, derived, ormanu-factured in whole or in part from toluene, a product provided for in paragraph 1651. The claim of the plaintiff was therefore sustained.  