
    Joseph P. Hershberger v. Charles E. Gibson et al.
    
    No. 15,854.
    (100 Pac. 1135.)
    Error from Kiowa district court; Gordon L. Finley, judge.
    Opinion filed March 6, 1909.
    Reversed.
    
      John Bailey, and George E. McMahon, for plaintiff in error.
    
      Clifford Misted, Charles Blood Smith, and Samuel Barnum, for defendants in error.
   Per Curiam:

The only question involved in this case is the validity of a tax deed. The court below held it invalid. The deed was issued and recorded more than five years before the beginning of the action, and every objection raised against the deed has been decided adversely by this court. (Robbins v. Brower, 74 Kan. 113, 85 Pac. 815; Penrose v. Cooper, 71 Kan. 725, 81 Pac. 489; Gibson v. Trisler, 73 Kan. 397, 85 Pac. 413; John v. Young, 74 Kan. 865, 86 Pac. 295; Kennedy v. Scott, 72 Kan. 359, 83 Pac. 971; Pierce v. Adams, 77 Kan. 46, 93 Pac. 594; Gibson v. Freeland, 77 Kan. 450, 94 Pac. 782; Ham v. Booth, 72 Kan. 429, 83 Pac. 24; Trust Co. v. Davis, 76 Kan. 639, 92 Pac. 707; Havel v. Abstract Co., 76 Kan. 336, 91 Pac. 790.) The judgment is therefore reversed, and the case is remanded with instructions to hold the deed valid and to proceed accordingly.  