
    The State, ex rel. Rausch, v. Taylor, Dir. of Dept. of Liquor Control. The State, ex rel. Bloch, v. Taylor, Dir. of Dept. of Liquor Control. The State, ex rel. Meinecke, v. Taylor, Dir. of Dept. of Liquor Control. The State, ex rel. Platz, v. Taylor, Dir. of Dept. of Liquor Control.
    (Nos. 27581, 27913, 27945 and 27952
    Decided March 27, 1940.)
    
      
      Mr. Joseph F. Hogan, for relator in cause No. 27581.
    
      Mr. Jerome Goldman, for relators in causes Nos. 27913, 27945 and 27952.
    
      Mr. Thomas J. Herbert, attorney general, Mr. E. G. Schuessler, Mr. John P. Walsh and Mr. Howard Bernstein, for respondent in cause No. 27581.
    
      Mr. Thomas J. Herbert, attorney general, Mr. John P. Walsh and Mr. Howard Bernstein, for respondent in causes Nos. 27913, 27945 and 27952.
   By the Court.

Each of the appointments having been made before and not after the Civil Service Commission certified the nominees for appointment as required by Section 486-14, General Code, a writ of man-damns is denied each relator on authority of State, ex rel. Lynch, v. Taylor, Dir., ante, 417.

Writs denied.

Weygandt, C. J., Day, Zimmerman, Williams, Matthias and Hart, JJ., concur.

Myers, J., dissents.  