
    Charlie Steve LEE and Mary Ellen Lee, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. SOUTHERN SILICA OF LOUISIANA, et al., Defendants-Appellants.
    No. 91-1393.
    Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.
    Feb. 3, 1993.
    Baggett, McCall & Burgess by William B. Baggett, Roger G. Burgess, Lake Charles, for plaintiffs.
    Pitre, Yoes, Kay & Halley by Henry E. Yoes, III, Blaine A. Doucet, Mesonie T. Halley, Jr., Lake Charles, for Clemtex, Ltd.
    
      Guillory & McCall by Robert E. Guillory, Jr., Lake Charles, for Fireman’s Fund Ins. Co.
    Weller, Wheelus & Green by David L. Tolin, Beaumont, TX, for Fibreboard Corp. and Pittsburgh Corning Corp.
    Forman, Perry, Watkins & Krutz by Richard L. Forman, Ronald D. Collins, John D. Cosmieh, Jackson, MS, for Owens-Illinois, Inc., and Keene Corp.
    Kirkland, Barfield & Panter by Thomas L. Kirkland, Jr., David A. Barfield, Jackson, MS, for AC and S.
    Bergstedt & Mount by Thomas M. Bergstedt, Lake Charles, for Owens-Illinois, Inc., and Keene Corp.
    Stockwell, Sievert, Viccellio, Clements & Shaddock by Emmett C. Sole, John Bradford, Thomas G. Henning, Paul L. Veasey, Jr., Lake Charles, for Pangborn Corp., Da-vey Compressors, Hartford Acc. & Indemn. Co., Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., Travelers In-demn. Co., PPG Industries, Inc., Murray Davis, Les Wilcox, Ben Walker, Shadye Paulk, Bob Moss, Joe Galanie, Will Lawrence, Don Savoy.
    Simon, Peragine, Smith & Redfearn by Daniel J. Caruso, Elizabeth Reidy Leach, New Orleans, for DeVilbiss Co.
    Demartini, Leblanc, D’Aquila & Volk by Jerome M. Volk, Jr., Mark J. Armato, Ken-ner, for Liberty Mut. Ins. Co.
    Landry, Watkins & Bonin by Nan M. Landry, New Iberia, for Empire Abrasive Equipment Co.
    Brame, Bergstedt & Brame by J. Gregory Bergstedt, Lake Charles, for Broth, of Painters and Decorators Allied Trades Local 783.
    Hulse, Nelson & Wanek by Craig R. Nelson, New Orleans, for Clemco Industries, Inc., E.D. Bullard Co.
    Lemle, Kelleher, Kohlmeyer, Dennery, Hunley, Moss & Frilot by Michael T. Cali, John J. Hainkel, III, Francis B. Mulhall, New Orleans, for Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co.
    Raggio, Cappel, Chozen & Berniard by M. Keith Prudhomme, Frederick L. Cappel, Lake Charles, for Thornstenberg Materials Co., Inc.
    Duplass, Witman & Zwain by Gary M. Zwain, Metairie, for Pulmosan Safety Equipment Corp.
    Carmouche Law Firm by David R. Frohn, Lake Charles, for Mine Safety Appliances Co.
    Preis, Kraft, Laborde & Daigle by Christopher R. Phillip, Edwin G. Preis, Gregory J. Laborde, Jeansonne & Briney by Katherine Loos, Lafayette, for Southern Silica of La., Inc.
    Benckenstein, Oxford, Radford & Johnson by William M. Tolin, III, Beaumont, TX, for Big Three Industries, a/k/a San-storm.
    Watson, Blanche, Wilson & Posner by Mary H. Thompson, Baton Rouge, for Sul-lair Corp.
    Christovich & Kearney by Geoffrey P. Snodgrass, New Orleans, for AC and S.
    Plauche, Smith & Nieset by Christopher P. Ieyoub, James R. Nieset, Lake Charles, for Specialty Sand Co.
    Pugh & Boudreaux by James R. Shelton, Lafayette, for Northwest Min. Corp. and Travelers Ins. Co.
    Allen, Gooch, Bourgeois, Breaux, Robi-son and Theunissen by St. Paul Bourgeois, IV, Jere Jay Bice, Lafayette, for Bob Schmidt, Inc.
    Taylor, Porter, Brooks & Phillips by John I. Moore, John Michael Parker, Baton Rouge, for L.L. Sline, Charles E. Fox, Dennis R. Lack, Roy R. Brock, Gene E. Miller, M.R. Sline, David Earle, Sherbert “Red” Richards and Marvin Zoch.
    Jones, Tete, Nolen, Hanchey, Swift & Spears by Kenneth R. Spears, Gregory W. Belfour, William B. Swift, William R. Tete, Lake Charles, for Oxy Oil & Gas USA, Inc., Ins. Co. of North America and Cities Service Co.
    Henderson, Hanemann & Morris by Charles Hanemann, Houma, for Minnesota Min. and Mfg. Co.
    Simon Peragine, Smith & Redfearn by Daniel J. Caruso, Daniel Lund, III, Maurice E. Bostick, New Orleans, for Pennsylvania Glass & Sand.
    Onebane, Donohoe, Bernard, Torian, Diaz, McNamara & Abell by Rebecca F. Doherty, Patrick J. Hanna, Lafayette, for Lone Star Industries.
    Edward H. Green, Beaumont, TX, for Pittsburgh Corning Corp.
    Stephen P. Hall, New Orleans, for Lloyds of London.
    Deutsch, Kerrigan & Stiles by Janet L. MacDonell, New Orleans, for Armstrong World Industries Inc., Flexitallic Gasket Inc., GAF Corp., Nat. Gypsum Co., Whig-ley Co., U.S. Gypsum Co., and Turner & Newell PLC.
    Maria I.O. Stephenson, Lisa C. Matthews, Earl N. Vaughan, New Orleans, for Rock Wool Mfg., Inc.
    Gregory E. Bodin, Lafayette, for Sline Indus. Painters Executive Officers, and Gene E. Miller.
    Galloway, Johnson, Tompkins & Burr, by Larry Canada, New Orleans, for Combustion Engineering, Inc.
    Laborde & Neuner by James L. Pate, Ben L. Mayeaux, Lafayette, for Binks Mfg. Co. and M.H. Detrick Co., Grant Wilson Inc.
    Scofield, Gerard, Veron, Hoskins & Soi-leau by John R. Pohorelsky, Lake Charles, for Reliance Ins. Co.
    Abbott, Webb, Best & Meeks' by Lawrence E. Abbott, Gary P. Landry, New Orleans, for E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co., Inc.
    Lozes, Cooper & Cambre by John J. Cooper, New Orleans, for Joy Mfg. Co.
    Adams & Reese by Edward J. Rice, Jr., Rebecca A. Bush, New Orleans, for Vallen Corp.
    Juneau, Judice, Hill & Adley by Marc W. Judice, Kathleen F. Drew, Lafayette, for H.K. Porter Co., Inc.
    O’Neil, Eichin, Miller & Breckinridge by Lindsay A. Larson, III, New Orleans, for Davey Compressor Co.
    Jones, Walker, Waechter, Poitevent, Carrere & Denegre by William Joyce, Donald 0. Collins, Vivian L. Madison, New Orleans, for Ingersoll Rand Co. and Aetna Life and Cas. Co.
    Caffery, Oubre, Dugas & Campbell, by David Dugas, New Iberia, for Gustin-Ba-con.
    Guillory & McCall by William T. McCall, Lake Charles, for Ins. of North America.
    Lawrence G. Pugh, III, New Orleans, for Carey-Canada Inc.
    Alan Weinberger, New Orleans, for Travelers Indemn.
    Before GUIDRY, STOKER and COOKS, JJ.
   STOKER, Judge.

For the reasons stated in Doiron v. Southern Silica of Louisiana, 613 So.2d 1064 (La.App. 3d Cir.1993), No. 91-1385 on the docket of this court, we affirm the judgment of the trial court. We assess costs of this appeal to CLEMTEX, LTD.

AFFIRMED.  