
    [No. 7658.
    
      En Banc.
    
    November 4, 1909.]
    J. B. Cordiner, Appellant, v. Minnie L. Kirkendall et al., Respondents.2
    
    Appeal from a judgment of tbe superior court for Chelan county, Steiner, J., entered July 14, 1908.
    Affirmed.
    
      Cordiner & Cordiner and J. C. Kleher, for appellant.
    
      Reeves & Reeves, for respondents.
   Per Curiam.

This action involves tbe question determined in tbe case of Cordiner v. Dear, ante p. 479, 104 Pac. 780, and is affirmed on tbe grounds stated in tbe opinion in that case.  