
    Samuel G. Metcalf, Rec'r, App'lt, v. Jose A. DelValle, Impl'd, Resp't.
    
      Glumies A. Murphey, for app’lt;
    
      L. 8. JIulse, for resp’t.
   Judgment affirmed, with costs, on authority of Bostwick v. Menck, 40 N. Y., 383. All concur, except Earl, J., dissenting.

Affirming 46 St. Rep., 105.  