
    Jesse M. Hughes et al., Respondents, v. Henry Billinghurst, impleaded, etc., Appellant.
    (Argued December 18, 1872;
    decided December 24, 1872.)
    
      James O. Gochrane for the appellant.
    
      M A. Raymond for the respondents.
   All concur for affirmance on opinion of Gardner, referee.

Judgment affirmed.  