
    McGUIGAN v. HENNESY.
    (Circuit Court, S. D. New York.
    June 9, 1905.)
    Albert A. Wray, for plaintiff.
    Frederick E. Fishel, for defendant.
   WALLACE, Circuit Judge.

I have carefully considered the brief of counsel for the plaintiff, and have reconsidered the correctness of my ruling upon the trial directing a verdict for the defendant. I am satisfied that the direction was correct, and that upon the case presented to the jury the plaintiff was not entitled to recover. Judgment is accordingly ordered for the defendant, pursuant to the verdict of the jury.  