
    Cluett v. McNeany.
    
      Mr. S. A. Duncan and Mr. J. A. Shilton for appellants.
   Appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York; No. 175. Argued with No. 174. As this case also turns upon the validity of the same patent the decree of the <jourt below is

Affirm

Mr. David Tim, for appellees.

Mr. Justice Blatchfobd did not sit in this case, and took no part in its decision.  