
    Henry J. Byrne et al., co-executors and co-trustees under the last will and testament of Henry Byrne, deceased, complainants-respondents, v. Henry J. Byrne et al., defendants-appellants, and Henry J. Byrne et al., defendants-respondents.
    [Submitted May term, 1938.
    Decided September 16th, 1938.]
    
      Mr. John Q. Flanigan (Mr. Paul J. Duffy, of counsel), for the appellants.
    
      Messrs. Milton, McNulty <& Augelli, for the complainants-respondents.
    
      Mr. Clarence F. McGovern, for the defendants-respondents Mary Brady, August Coleman and Annie Byrne.
    
      Messrs. Burlce, Sheridan \& Hourigan (Mr. Fdmund B. Hourigan, of counsel), for the defendant-respondent Henry J. Byrne.
   Per Curiam.

We are in accord with the conclusion of the learned vice-chancellor that the annuities granted by the fourth clause of the will of Henry Byrne, deceased, are payable out of the income offiy, and are not a charge upon the corpus.

This is the sole question presented by the appeal; and the decree is accordingly affirmed.

For affirmance — The Chiee-Justice, Teenchabb, Pabeee, Case, Bobine, Donges, Hehee, Peeskie, Postee, Het-EIELB, Deas, WeKLS, WOLESKEIL, RaEEEETY, WaIjKEE, JJ. 15.

For reversal — None.  