
    Between Frederick W. Walker, appellant, and James C. Atwater, respondent.
    [Decided at November Term, 1863.]
    
      Bradley, for appellant.
    
      Zabriskie, for respondent.
   The decree of the Chancellor was affirmed by the following vote:

For affirmance—Judges Combs, Cornelison, Fort, Haines, Ogden, Van Dyke, Vredenburgh, Whelpley, Wales, Wood—10.

For reversal — None.  