
    ROSENTHAL vs. CIRCUIT JUDGE (Muskegon),
    No. 13860;
    98 M., 208; 22 L. R. A., 693.
   To compel respondent to enter an order restraining tbe use of certain evidence obtained by a plaintiff from books of account, cancelled checks, trial balances, and other books and papers of the defendant, which were taken under a writ of attachment and copies therefrom made, after which the books, etc., were returned and the attachment proceedings discontinued-

Granted December 22d, 1893, with costs.  