
    No. 12561.
    The State of Ohio v. Ruggles et al.
    Decided December 6, 1910.
    Exceptions to Common Pleas Court of Franklin county.
    
      Messrs. Webber, McCoy, King & Game, for the exceptions.
    
      Mr. Cyrus Huling; Mr. Ralph West-fall; Mr. E. D. Howard and Mr. James M. Butler, against the exceptions.
   Exceptions overruled, on the ground that the indictment does not sufficiently charge that the bill paid was not a valid claim against the state.

Crew, Shauck and Price, JJ., concur.  