
    SARAH VALEAU, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. ROBERT W. SMITH, Defendant and Appellant.
    Before Sedgwick and Van Vorst, JJ.
    
      Decided May 16, 1879.
    Appeal by defendant from judgment and from order denying motion for new trial. This case involves only questions of fact.
   Van Vorst, J.,

wrote for reversal of the judgment, with costs, to abide the event.

Sedgwick, J., concurred.  