
    (First Circuit — Hamilton Co., O., Circuit Court
    Oct. Term, 1899.)
    Before Smith, Swing and Giffen, JJ.
    CHARLES B. SHIELDS v. ELIZA BETTS et al.
    
      Failure to file petition in error within the statutory time—
    
      Wm. Hartley Pugh, for Plaintiffs in Error.
    
      Ellis B. Gregg, contra.
   SMITH, J

The motions will have to be granted. The petitions in error were not filed until five months after the rendition of the judgments sought to be reversed, and, therefore, were not filed in time. It is true that they were filed within four months from the overruling of the motion for a new trial, but this is not sufficient. 50 Ohio St., 299; 58 Ohio St., 395.  