
    John W. Chadwick, appellant, v. John Livesey, respondent.
    On appeal from a decree advised by Vice-Chancellor Stevens, whose opinion is reported in Livesey v. Jones, 10 Dick. Ch. Rep. 204.
    
    
      
      Mr. Francis Taylor and Mr. Esek Cowen (of New York), for the appellant.
    
      Mr. Edwin A. S. Lewis and Mr. Abel I. Smith, for the respondent.
   Per Curiam.

Decree affirmed, for the reasons given in the court of chancery.

For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Depue, Lippincott, Ludlow, Adams, Hendrickson, Nixon, Vredenburgh —8.

For reversal-Collins, Dixon, Garrison, Van Syckel —4.  