
    WILLIAM I. GARRISON, DEFENDANT IN ERROR, v. H. PHELPS REED, EXECUTOR OF I. WHILDEN MOORE, DECEASED, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR.
    Argued November 20, 1908
    Decided March 1, 1909.
    On error to the Supreme Court.
    For the plaintiff in error, Edward Ambler Armstrong and Thompson & Cole.
    
    For the defendant in error, John J. Crandall.
    
   Per CuRiasi.

As this case raises the same questions considered and disposed of in Fleming v. H. Phelps Reed, Executor of I. Whilden Moore, Deceased, ante p. 563, the judgment below, for the reasons given in that case, is affirmed, with costs.

For affirmance—The ChaNCelloR, Chief Justioe, Gae-RisoN, Swayze, Reed, Trexchaed, PaRiíer, BergeN, Yoor-itees, MiNtuRN, Bogert, VeedeNburgh, Veoom, Gray, Dill, J.J. 15.

For reversal—None.  