
    CHARLES H. PERKINS, Resp’t, v. JOHN THORP, App’lt.
    Appeal from a judgment on the verdict of a jury and from an order, denyy ing a new trial.
    
      H. B. Smith, for pl’ff; J. W. Shea, for def’t.
   Boardman, J.

Judgment and order affirmed, with costs.

Hardin and Follett, JJ., concur.  