
    CONRAD STRUCKMAN ET AL. v. THE UNITED STATES.
    [44 C. Cls. R., 202.
    Not reported in U. S. R.]
    
      On the claimants' Appeal.
    
    The suit is to recover back duties illegally collected in the Philippines. The facts are identical with those in ileinsgen (42 C. Cls. It., 58, 206), except that in this case the goods were imported from Spain and in Heinszen from the United States.
    
      The court below decides:
    I. The Treaty with 8pain (30 Stat. L., p. 1754) does not give to merchaiuliso imported into the Philippines from Spain a different status from that imported from the United States.
    XL Neither does the treaty give a preference to a citizen of Spain over a citizen of the United States in the matter of importation. They are entitled to the same terms.
   The demurrer of the defendants is sustained and the claimants’ petition dismissed.

The decision of the court below is affirmed December 4, 1911, without an opinion. *  