
    BADISCHE ANILIN & SODA FABRIK v. MATHESON et al.
    (Circuit Court. S. D. New York.
    June 8, 1899.)
    Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Livingston Gifford, for the motion.
    Henry P. Wells, opposed.
   LACOMBE, Circuit Judge.

Judge Coxa lias held this patent valid, having before him the very evidence as to the Casella German patent and as to the publica lions in this country on which defendant seems to rely. 94 Fed. 163. This court therefore starts with the proposition that the patent is valid, and, since it is not disputed that defendant’s product responds to all the tests of the patent, it must be held to be an infringement.  