
    RODOLPHUS BINGHAM ET AL., PLAINTIFFS IN ERROR, v. THEODORE B. GIBBS ET AL., DEFENDANTS IN ERROR.
    Error to the Supreme Court.
    For the plaintiffs in error, J. J. Crandall.
    For the defendants in error, S. H. Grey.
    
   Per Curiam.

The judgment in this case should be affirmed for the reasons given by the Supreme Court.

For affirmance — The Chancellor, Chief Justice, Depue, Dixon, Parker, Reed, Scudder, Brown, Cole, Paterson, Whitaker. 11.

For reversal — None.  