
    Ralph R. Pullen, appellant, v. Catharine A. Pullen, respondent.
    In this case an order was made, January 15th, 1889, by the advice of Vice-Chancellor Bird, suppressing-certain affidavits offered by the defendant in bar of the allowance of alimony and counsel fees.
    A further order was made, February 8th, 1889, granting alimony and counsel fees.
    From these orders the defendant appealed. The appeals from said orders came on to be heard together.
    
      
      Mr. O. O. Vanderbilt, for the appellant.
    
      Mr. IF. Y. Johnson, for the respondent.
   Orders affirmed.

For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Dixon, Garrison, Knapp, Magie, Van Syokel, Brown, Clement, Cole, McGregor, Smith, Whitaker — 12.

For reversal — None.  