
    HAWORTH, Respondent, v. ENGINEER CO., Appellant.
    (Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department.
    June 8, 1906.)
    Action by Lloyd B. Haworth against the Engineer Company impleaded. A. H. McMahon for appellant. ~F. F. Donnelly, for respondent.
   PER CtJRIAM.

Order affirmed, with $1C costs and disbursements. Order filed.

PATTERSON and INGRAHAM, JJ., dis~ sent.  