
    No. 6043.
    State ex rel. Attorney General v. Ratterman et al.
    (Decided December 6, 1898.)
    Quo Warranto on rehearing.
    
      F. S. Monnett, Attorney General; John Warring-ton; W. H. Ampt; and I). J. Ryan, for plaintiff.
    
      Foiled da Kelley; Peck da Shafer and Goechel da Bettinger, for defendants.
   Former judgment adherred to.

Bradbury, Shaucx and Burket, JJ., dissent.  