
    No. 9041.
    Ralston v. The City of Defiance.
    (Decided May 9, 1905.)
    Error to Circuit Court of Defiance county.
    
      Mr. J. W. Slough and Mr. B. B. Kingsbury, for plaintiff in error.
    
      Mr. W. D. Hill, for defendant in error.
   Judgment reversed and judgment for the plaintiff in error.

Davis, C. J., Shauck, Price and Summers, JJ., concur.  