
    No. 5298.
    Cottell v. The State.
    (Decided November 17, 1896.)
    Error to the Circuit Court of Summit county.
    
      Fckoin F. Vorhes and Han'vey Musser, for plaintiff in error.
    
      F. S. Monnett, Attorney General, and B. M. Wanamaker, for defendant in error.
   Judgment reversed and cause remanded for a new trial on the authority of Kelch v. The State, 55 Ohio St., 146, for error in the charge of the court as to the degree of proof required to establish defense of insanity. No other error is found in the record.

Minseall, J., dissents.  